Holiday Inn Midtown / 57th St, New York City, Negative

OpinionWell's Blog

Home » United States » New York » New York Destinations » New York Hotels » Holiday Inn Midtown / 57th St

OpinionWell
Rank

58th

Out of 676

Holiday Inn Midtown / 57th St	Average Price: $293 Check Rates

Hotel Class:

440 West 57th Street

New York City, 10019 View map

2-Star Hotel Rank: 6 of 144
Average review rating: 3.48

OpinionWell Value Index: 4

Traveler reviews analyzed: Expedia (38) , MyTravelGuide (135) , Travelocity (52) , TripAdvisor (967) , YahooTravel (46)

SAFE TO BOOK ? (4/5 issues found)

Is this hotel safe to book? See the trends in negative comments below to find out the real deal before you commit:

Construction:	There are recent comments about Construction, Renovation.
Noise:	Recent comments complained about noise.
Room Smell:	Recent comments complained about room smell.
Parking Fees:	No recent comments about parking fees were found.
Bed Bugs:	Recent comments complained about bed bugs.

Search reviews for other problems

Keyword Cloud

The hotel review keyword cloud displays the words commonly used to describe the features and services of this hotel. Select a word and explore.

All Positive Negative

Keyword Search

avoid (13) awful (15) bad (111) bed bugs (26) bit dated (10) broken (18) chipped (10) complain (44) complaint (29) cramped (10) dated (41) dirty (50) disappoint (46) disgust (17) expensive (65) hard (32) horrible (18) inconvenient (10) issue (57) lack (17) loud (27) mice (17) mildew (11) mistake (11) mold (45) negative (28) noise (91) noisy (47) outdated (26) overpriced (11) peeling (13) poor (25) problem (122) rat (12) rodent (10) rude (62) shabby (14) shock (12) slow (43) smell (86) stained (10) terrible (27) tiny (17) too small (9) uncomfortable (14) unfortunate (20) unhelpful (12) worn (28) worst (29) wrong (25)

Negative

Appears in 33 comments.

The following words were used in comments with Negative:
condition (2) elevator (5) experience (3) few (3) holiday (7) hotel (14) inn (7) liked (3) location (4) new (3) not (6) positive (5) recommend (3) reviews (8) room (7) small (4) staff (5) street (3) toilets (4) well (3)

Users can vote for helpful comments, which are saved in the Most helpful section.

Sort by:

See all

1. Because the statements were so vehement about the negative aspects of the hotel I only reserved one night of a necessary three.

"Found this to be a good find! " Read full review on TripAdvisor 1/11/2012 Vote

2. Very negative and disappointing experience.

"Large rooms but need renovation, bad service " Read full review on TripAdvisor 10/21/2011 Vote

3. 5) front desk staff were EXTREMELY unfriendly and disrespectful6) air conditioning unit was broken on the last evening7) elevators were very small and shook ALOT as it movedthere's not enough room on here to write all the negatives of our stay.

"couldn't leave fast enough! " Read full review on TripAdvisor 10/18/2011 Vote

4. negative points: For the first 4 days of our stay one of the three very small elevators was out of service.

"not recommended " Read full review on TripAdvisor 9/17/2011 Vote

5. only negative is the air conditioner in our room did not work very well.

"NYC WEEKEND " Read full review on TripAdvisor 5/23/2011 Vote

6. The staff were always very pleasant towards us and had no negative experiences, even with us seeing them at least daily for our safety deposit box.

"Generally a fine hotel, no major complaints! " Read full review on TripAdvisor 3/16/2011 Vote

7. We have travelled all over the world and stayed in various levels of accommodation and I can honestly say my friend & I were both very impressed with The holiday Inn - so if you're due to stay here, don't worry about the negative reviews, there's just no pleasingn some folk - Enjoy New York, we did.

"amazing time - hotel perfect " Read full review on TripAdvisor 12/10/2010 Vote

8. Can't believe some of the negative reviews on this site - some people are just serial complainers.

"amazing time - hotel perfect " Read full review on TripAdvisor 12/10/2010 Vote

9. The only negative thing I would say is in our room the curtains were for decoration purposes only and wouldn't close.

"Value for money, spacious rooms, better than expected. " Read full review on TripAdvisor 11/21/2010 Vote

10. We had booked this hotel with Virgin and then checked out trip advisor and got rather worried as some people were making negative comments about the Holiday Inn at West 57th Street.

"Great! " Read full review on TripAdvisor 9/12/2010 Vote