3. , just returned from one nights stay at the Pierre in NY City, i am not sure what is with the Negative reviews, this hotel was first class all the way,booked a superior room was upgraded to a two bedroom suite,soft king size bed,the other room had a couch and a desk, the room service was excellent, , as was the dinning at the caffe pierre we where celebrating our wedding anniversary, ,they sent up wine and cheese and fruit i have stayed at other 5 star hotels, such as the ritz carlton nothing compares to the experience we had at this hotel if you can try to get a room on the 12th floor,you are right on 5th ave and central park, the location can not be beat, with all the 5 star hotels in NY city, this is one of the nicest.