6. I can't say enough good things about this hotel but I'll share a few: CLEAN and updated, great FULL breakfasts (eggs, potatoes, bacon, sausage, pancakes or waffles, and fresh fruit, juice and coffee); convenient restaurant (great menu and quality food too) on site for those evenings you just want to stay in; unlike Hotel Circle, this area provides miles of walking trails along the Bay in Shelter Island Park; great location within the City, close to downtown and other attractions; coastal location with great views of the City or the Marina; great value for the $$; and we love the staff many of whom have been with them for several years.